Dr. Carolyn M. Tucker’s Mentoring
Style and Its Effectiveness in Doctoral Education
Mentoring
Style.
For many years I have described my
mentoring style as empowerment-oriented, culturally
sensitive, holistic, compassionate, and excellence
driven. This is still the
case; however, my graduate students have helped me see
that another important aspect of my mentoring style is
giving them support, encouragement, and priority,
whether or not they want to become a researcher like me.
This
“unconditional supportive mentoring” has enabled many
students to achieve success under adverse conditions
that exist in their lives. It is thus this
“unconditional supportive mentoring” that is now an
added source of my mentoring pride.
Indeed, having been a mentor for
over 30 years, I have learned that academic/research
mentoring is insufficient without additionally giving
the personal support and caring that students often
need to cope with such challenges as not feeling a sense
of belonging in their graduate program and dealing with
financial, health, relationship, and family problems.
Thus, my
mentoring of students involves time-consuming but
personally rewarding activities, such as periodically
taking them to breakfast, lunch, or dinner to simply
discuss their support needs and develop strategies for
meeting these needs; finding time to meet with their
parents and family members; arranging for them to
receive a meal and/or groceries when they are ill;
initiating meetings with them just to talk about
whatever is on their mind; and always being available to
them via my personal cell phone. I am most proud,
however, of my atypical “going above and beyond
mentoring,” which is exemplified by choosing to spend
hours in emergency rooms and hospitals to be with
students who become seriously ill, or choosing to spend
eight consecutive months serving as a patient
representative for a terminally-ill student because his
parents did not speak English well and asked me to serve
this role. Indeed, “going
above and beyond mentoring” often is not easy, but as my
grandfather told me repeatedly, “anything worth doing
ain’t easy.”
I strongly believe that this type of mentoring is
indeed worth doing.
I am also deeply
passionate about the more academic and research training
aspects of my mentoring. These mentoring
aspects involve actively and deliberately creating “real
world” opportunities for my culturally diverse graduate
students to actually engage in culturally sensitive
research, teaching, mentoring, leadership, consultation,
and community service. Many of these
“real world” opportunities occur as part of my
grant-funded community-participatory research programs
to promote culturally sensitive health care and health
promotion in racial/ethnic minority and low-income
communities. Students report
that these opportunities teach them valuable lessons
about cultural differences and similarities, the need
for culturally sensitive theories and research that
reflect real-world realities, and ways to integrate
intervention science into community settings—and to do
so in a way that enables fidelity of the science while
also fitting the science to the community structures and
promoting structural justice in the intervention
dissemination processes. These are lessons
that cannot be learned in a textbook, but are important
for the emerging generation of researchers and national
leaders in any field who will have the challenge of
working in an increasingly more diverse world. I continue to be
surprised by the excitement with which my graduate
students embrace these lessons.
The ways in which my graduate
students (who I call my research associates) participate
in one of my two current community-based/participatory
research projects may help convey how I strive to
empower them to be able to become culturally sensitive
and first-rate researchers, teachers, mentors, leaders,
consultants, and community service providers. This project is
my grant-funded community-based Health-Smart Church
Project, which aims to promote health behaviors and
reduce body-mass index levels among African American
women and their families. Members of both
my Behavioral Medicine Research Team (which currently
includes 4 graduate students, 30 undergraduate students,
and 2 community members) and my Health Psychology
Research Team (which currently includes 4 graduate
students and 25 undergraduate students) co-direct and
implement this project. The experiences
of the graduate students (who have empowering titles
such as Director of Data Management) include assisting
with writing the grant that funded the project,
attending African American church services to recruit
research participants and then collecting data from them
after church, conducting health promotion workshops for
project participants, setting up participants’ churches
to be health promotion centers, training church leaders
and pastors to be health empowerment coaches, and
training and co-mentoring undergraduate students to
assist with all aspects of the project. I initially
assumed major leadership in all of these activities, and
then gradually turned over this leadership to my
graduate students as I increasingly assumed the primary
role of observing, supporting, and praising them, and
promoting their self-empowerment for success. The latter is
anchored in my self-empowerment model of achievement
(Tucker, 1999) which asserts that the goal of education
is to promote self-motivation to learn, self-control in
the learning process, self-praise of success efforts and
outcomes, skills and experiences for goal achievement,
and success behaviors (such as asking for wanted and
needed support).
Evidence of
Mentoring Effectiveness. There is
much evidence of the effectiveness of my mentoring
style, including the following: (a) I have received
numerous cards, letters, and gifts from graduate student
mentees and their parents thanking me for mentoring
them; (b) of the 21 graduate students whose
dissertations I chaired over just the past 10 years, 4
received highly competitive CLAS Outstanding
Dissertation Awards, 3 received Landsman Outstanding
Student Awards, 2 received Outstanding International
Student Awards, 1 received an Outstanding Graduate
Student Teacher Award, and 2 received external
outstanding research awards; (c) all but 1 of the 12
graduate student mentees whose Master’s or Dissertation
Committee I presently chair have presented research
papers at national/regional conferences, and all but 1
have refereed research publications; and (d) of the 33
graduate student mentees who have received their PhD
degree under my supervision, 21 are employed at
universities—6 are associate or full professors in
academic departments (1 is a department chair), 14 are
psychologists at university counseling/mental health
centers, 2 are the recipients of large NIMH grants, and
1 was recently an NIMH Research Fellow. Additionally,
84% of these 33 graduated mentees are engaged in
research or have job-related and/or profession-related
leadership roles, and most are also engaged in community
service.
Two other strong indicators of my
mentoring effectiveness are the extraordinarily large
number of graduate students who have chosen me as their
Master’s and/or Dissertation research
mentor/chairperson, and the cultural diversity
represented by these students. Specifically, I
have had 40 graduate student mentees receive Master’s
degrees (20 Whites, 15 Blacks, including 3 from outside
the U.S., 3 Hispanics, and 2 Asians) and 33 receive PhD
degrees (19 Whites, 14 Blacks) under my supervision.
Fourteen
(35%) of the Master’s degree recipients and 21 (64%) of
the PhD recipients received their degrees over the past
10 years. Currently, I
officially serve as mentor and committee chair for a
culturally diverse group of 12 graduate or doctoral
students (7 Whites, 3 Blacks, 1 Asian, and 1 Hispanic),
among whom are 8 doctoral candidates.
I am extremely proud of the
diversity and large number of the graduate students whom
I have mentored and of their impressive research and
career success. I am most proud, however, that I have
empowered majority students and minority students with
learning experiences that will enable them to do their
life’s work “with an ear for the beat of different
hearts.”